Case 06Toptal · Growth Experience

More of the right freelancers, before the client asks

Toptal promises clients a top freelancer, fast. When the network ran short of React developers, that promise broke and the deal walked. I was the first designer on Toptal's Growth Experience team, and I led the squad whose pages brought freelancers in.

CompanyToptal, a network of freelance developers, designers and experts
My roleFirst designer on Growth Experience (GX). Lead designer, Talent Growth
Team2 designers, a PO, engineers and QA, with the SEO team alongside
WhenApril 2019 to February 2023
01The problem

A shortage is a lost client.

A client arrives with a demand, Toptal promises someone quickly, and then nobody in the network has the skill. The gaps were always the same ones: React, JavaScript, most front-end work, product design.

Our pages had one job: be clear and convincing enough that the right newcomers start signing up. The old freelancer homepage couldn't do it, for two reasons. It took real work to change, so it couldn't follow the market. And it spoke to everyone at once, so a React developer never saw a page about React, or a reason to think they could make Toptal's top 3%.

  1. TemplateOne landing page per skill, launched without a designer.
  2. SearchEvery skill page one link from the homepage.
  3. FilterA one-minute screen before the sign-up, so volume didn't drown quality.
  4. SystemA component library under all of it, so the next page was cheaper than the last.
02Template

One page, every skill.

I designed the template, its blocks and the rules it runs on. The skill is a variable: it lands in the headline, the pitch and the button.

The PO fed in the data, so any PO could launch a page for a new skill without waiting for a designer. Toptal made as many as the market needed. The POs took over the routine launches, since they were watching the numbers anyway, and I spent design time on the pages that needed thinking.

One block came from legal. Search brings people in on brand names like Shopify, so every page states that the job is with Toptal's clients, not with the brand.

One landing page template at two widths. The headline reads 'Remote Freelance Shopify Developer Jobs with Top Global Clients', the button 'Apply as a Shopify Developer', and a small line underneath says this is not a role at Shopify itself but with Toptal clients who use it.
The template, set for Shopify. The skill fills the headline and the button; the small line under it is the legal block.
The freelancer homepage hero: 'Remote Freelance Jobs With Top Global Clients', an Apply to Join button, a video link and a strip of client logos.
The generic homepage hero, the page the template grew from. Swap the skill and the same page speaks to Shopify developers, as above.
04Filter

Growth that doesn't fill the funnel with no.

Toptal takes the top 3%. Every extra applicant is mostly an extra rejection, and a rejection costs the applicant's time and Toptal's screeners'. So we put a filter in front of the funnel.

The 1-Minute Talent Assessment sits on the homepage, ahead of the big ask. It checks English and a few hard skills, and gives a straight answer either way.

A homepage card titled '1-Minute Talent Assessment': 'Do you have what it takes to join Toptal as a React.js Developer?', with a Start here button.
On the homepage, set to the skill the page is about.

Not ready yet

We said what Toptal looks for, so the answer read as a plan rather than a rejection.

Ready

Congratulated, and sent into sign-up with a couple of steps already done.

05The pitch

Show the work you won't have to do.

Freelancers know the grind: portfolio, prospecting, consultations, invoices. The homepage draws it.

Seven steps on the traditional side, three on Toptal's. Below it, the proof in the order the doubts arrive: who the clients are, what freelancers rate Toptal, what they say, then the questions. Beside the pages sat a freelancer calculator, with an hourly rate and what it adds up to as hourly, part-time or full-time work. Its job was to make "good money" a number you could see.

'What Sets Toptal Apart?': two paths from one point. Traditional Freelancing runs seven steps, from Advertise Your Services to Send Invoices and Ensure Payment. Toptal runs three: Submit your application, Screening Process, Work with Clients and get paid on time.
Seven steps against three. The traditional path stays grey; Toptal's is the one in colour.
06The test

Three carousels, tested on ten freelancers.

The Ultimate Freelancing Guide was a lead magnet, built for people who wanted in and needed to know what it took. Its articles sat in a carousel, and anyone who missed the navigation never got past the first card.

We tested three versions with 10 prospective freelancers, suggested by people already in the network: 5 developers, 2 designers, 2 product managers and 1 QA engineer. The task was to find the fourth article. Participants scored each version on a seven-point ease scale. Our PO ran the sessions.

  • Prototype 0148
  • Prototype 0257
  • Prototype 0362
I have to scroll down the page to find the navigationOn 01 · arrows below the fold
It was easier to find the navigation but the arrows mix with the content…On 02 · arrows over the cards
This was the easiest to find.On 03 · arrows on the hero, in view
The results board: three prototypes of the guide page side by side, each with its position, its points (48, 57, 62), the spread of ease ratings and the participants' comments. Prototype 03 carries a Winner badge.
The results board, as we kept it. Prototype 03 shipped.
07System

A library, so the next page cost less.

A template only scales if its parts do. I started the Public Pages Library in Sketch, then the team rebuilt it in Figma together.

It ran from atoms (type, sizes, corners, colour, spacing) up to whole components: buttons, forms, cards, floating elements. We documented each part on its own page: what it's made of, its spacing, how it behaves. We drew the visual refresh, a deeper blue with diagonal cuts, with the same parts.

The library, bottom up. Type, a button, elevation, components, rhythm, a page.
The Label component: six colour styles, each basic, with an icon or with a remove button, in active and hover states, at small and medium sizes.
One component, every state. The Label, in six colour styles.
A documentation page from 'Public Pages Library / Atomic Design System' for the Case Study atom: overview, spacing at 96 and 32 pixels, and interactions.
Every part had a page like this: what it's made of, its spacing, how it behaves.
Three hero directions from the visual refresh, all deep blue: 'Real People. Truly Talented.', 'Remote freelance done right.' over a diagonal cut, and 'Quit your commute. Keep your career.'
The refresh, three hero directions. Built from the same library.
08Where it landed

Zero shortages within six months.

After years of constant shortfall, the network had no freelancer shortages within six months of our team taking over the pages.

That came from our work: we redesigned the pages and rebuilt them for search.

Andre is a designer who deeply understands the business context. He is interested in knowing the motivation of the users, in how they are using our product, and in what happens to them when they are no longer within the scope of our product.

Eugene Aleksandrov · Product Manager · Toptal
09Hindsight

What I'd do differently

  1. Own the numbers as well as the pages.Our PO ran the experiments and I got the results. I can show four years of design and almost none of what it moved. Next time I'd keep a record of every test I designed for: what we expected, what happened.
  2. Get the system into Figma sooner.The library started in Sketch, and moving it took the whole team. Every month in between, we had two sources of truth.